Human induced vibration: Why engineers should always consider it

​The concept of human induced vibration (vibrations caused by human footfall) can conjure up images of Millennium Bridge-style swaying or collapsing buildings. But, in reality, the ‘damage’ caused by human induced vibrations is less likely to ruin a structure and more likely to cause discomfort for people using it – By Amy Hodgett

Though not as dramatic as a structural failure, any good engineer wants to make sure the people using their structures, be it bridges, buildings or anything in between, can do so safely and comfortably. This is why human induced vibration must be considered by engineers within the design process.

Impulse vs Resonance

Resonant and impulse or transient are the two ways that human-induced vibrations impact structures.

When Object A vibrates at the same natural frequency as Object B, resonance occurs. Object B resonates with this and begins to vibrate too. Think singing to break a wine glass! Although the person singing isn’t touching the glass, the vibrations of their voice are resonating with the glass’s natural frequency, causing this vibration to get stronger and stronger and eventually, break the glass. In the case of a structure, resonance occurs when the pedestrian’s feet land in time with the vibration.

On structures where its natural frequency is too high for resonance to occur, like when the structure is stiff or light, impulse or transient vibration responses can be a problem. Here the discomfort is caused by the initial “bounce” of the structure caused by the footstep and is a concern on light or stiff structures.

Therefore, impulse or resonance must be considered by engineers, and structures must be designed to reduce the vibration effects of this.

The potential impacts of human induced vibration

There are several effects that human induced vibrations can have on the structure and its users. These include:

  • Swaying bridges. One of the most famous examples of human-induced resonance impacting a structure occurred with the Millennium Bridge. As people walked across the bridge, the footsteps caused the bridge to sway, and everybody had to walk in time with the sway because it was difficult not to. Thankfully, this feedback can only occur with horizontal vibrations so building floors are safe from it, but footbridges need careful checking to prevent it.
  • Interfering with sensitive equipment. Depending on the building’s purpose, what it houses can be affected by the vibrations of people using the building. Universities and laboratories, for example, may have sensitive equipment whose accuracy and performance could be damaged by vibrations. Even in ordinary offices the footfall vibration can wobble computer screens, upsetting the workers.
  • Jeopardising structural integrity. The build-up of constant vibrations on a structure can, eventually, lead to structural integrity being compromised. A worse-case scenario would be the complete collapse of the structure and is the reason some bridges insist that marching troops break step before crossing. Crowds jumping in time to music or in response to a goal in a stadium are also dynamic loads that might damage an under-designed structure.
  • Human discomfort. According to research, vibrations in buildings and structures can cause depression and even motion sickness in inhabitants. Tall buildings sway in the wind and footsteps can be felt, even subconsciously by the occupants. It has been argued that modern efficient designs featuring thinner floor slabs and wider spacing in column design mean that these new builds are not as effective at dampening vibrations as older buildings are.

Avoiding It

As previously discussed, the likes of wider column spacing and thinner slabs are both modern designs that can be susceptible to any form of vibration, whether this be human-induced or otherwise. However, short spans have a low mass and as a result, could also suffer. Using sophisticated structural design and analysis software is an effective method for engineers to test for and mitigate footfall and other vibrations at the design stage. If needs be, solutions such as retaining walls should also be considered.

Further Reading:

http://homepage.tudelft.nl/p3r3s/MSc_projects/reportRoos.pdf

https://phys.org/news/2017-03-impact-bridges-skyscrapers-human-health.html

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2017/03/19/wobbly-skyscrapers-may-trigger-motion-sickness-depression-warn/